More US companies are moving accounting, payroll, HR, IT and customer support into a shared service center in Mexico. The talent is there, the time zones match, and the work flows straight back to headquarters.
Most of these companies also assume that exporting services from Mexico comes with tax benefits built in. It does not. There are two primary routes to that rate:
They cover different activities, are structured differently, require different levels of ongoing compliance, and pose different risks. This blog goes into more detail.
A shared service center exports services when the work happens in Mexico but is used abroad. In other words: your team in Mexico closes the books, runs the payroll or answers support tickets, invoices your U.S. parent, and the value lands in the United States.
That binational setup is the whole point of the model. It is also exactly what Mexico's tax authority, the SAT (Servicio de Administración Tributaria) will ask you to prove.
That this means in practice: the center is usually a Mexican subsidiary that bills its U.S. parent company for services, often on a cost-plus basis. How that subsidiary is set up, staffed and documented decides which tax benefits it can actually use.
Article 29 of Mexico's VAT law (Ley del IVA, or LIVA) applies a 0% rate to services
Neither route is "set and forget". The difference is where the work sits. IMMEX front-loads compliance into a program you must maintain. Article 29 spreads it across every invoice and every refund claim. In both cases, mismanagement could lead to significant financial impacts and back tax assessment.
Read more in the Nearshoring Service Centers blog post.
IMMEX (Industria Manufacturera, Maquiladora y de Servicios de Exportación) is best known for manufacturing. Its services modality covers activities the Ministry of Economy (Secretaría de Economía) authorizes. For a shared service center, the relevant ones are:
The modality also covers services on physical goods, such as repair, maintenance, inspection, testing, storage and distribution.
The center can import computers, servers and telecom equipment without paying VAT upfront. It invoices a US entity, related or not, for the services it exports, and the U.S. parent company typically funds the operation.
Once the Ministry of Economy authorizes your program, keeping it is an ongoing obligation. In practice, that means:
Miss these and the risk is not a fine on one transaction. It is cancellation of the program, which turns your temporary imports into definitive ones, with duties and VAT due.
Article 29, section IV states that zero-rates are for services performed in Mexico and used abroad, but only for the activities it lists:
The SAT (Servicio de Administración Tributaria) and Mexican courts increasingly expect four things per billing period:
These services have to be contracted by a resident abroad without a permanent establishment in Mexico. They must also be paid for from bank accounts opened in foreign financial institutions. Including evidence of deliverable or other documentation that expressly demonstrates that the service was effectively used abroad.
There is no program, no IMMEX audit and no registered-address rule, and the same entity can serve Mexican affiliates at 16% VAT alongside foreign clients at 0%.
The SAT (Servicio de Administración Tributaria) and Mexican courts increasingly expect four things per billing period:
These services have to be contracted by a resident abroad without a permanent establishment in Mexico. They must also be paid for from bank accounts opened in foreign financial institutions. Including evidence of deliverable or other documentation that expressly demonstrates that the service was effectively used abroad.
Without a program, there is no annual report to file, but the burden of proof never goes away. Each month, your center:
Keep the file for at least five years, the general record-keeping period under Mexico's Federal Fiscal Code. A refund claim is effectively an audit you request yourself, so build the file before you file the claim.
Services invoiced at the 0% VAT rate that do not meet the requirements or do not demonstrate the evidence will be subject to the general 16% VAT rate, regardless of their actual utilization. This situation can have an economic impact, as VAT charged to residents abroad will not be recoverable. Compliance is judged on a case-by-case basis per invoice, so consistency and organization is crucial.
Both routes can reach the same 0% rate on exporting services from Mexico. They differ in which activities they cover, what they cost to run and what they let you do. Most centers fall into one of three situations:
|
Service IMMEX |
0% export VAT (Article 29) |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Activities covered |
Ministry of Economy-authorized services, including BPO (accounting, payroll, call centers, engineering, etc.) |
Listed services only, including technical assistance, IT services and call centers |
|
Clients |
Export only |
Foreign clients at 0%, Mexican clients at 16% |
|
Equipment |
Imported without paying VAT upfront |
VAT paid, then recovered |
|
Facility |
Registered address with a qualifying lease |
Any building |
|
Approval |
Ministry of Economy program |
None |
|
Proof required |
IMMEX audits and compliance documents |
Deliverable evidence for every invoice |
The tax rules are rarely the problem. The way the center is set up is.
Fundamentally the two routes support two different business plans. An IMMEX operation is a cost center where a foreign company, through their Mexican subsidiary, is effectively utilizing the Mexican workforce to deliver services to themselves. The invoice between the parties covers the cost of the operation, as they are funding it. When a company sells and delivers a service to a foreign resident abroad at 0% VAT, they are effectively charging the price or cost of the corresponding deliverable, and the Mexican operation serves as a profit center.
Robin Conklen, Managing Director USA
With Mindfacturing®, Prodensa's employer of record platform, you can hire your shared service center team in Mexico in 1 to 2 weeks while you choose your VAT route and build the contracts behind it. That is how one client moved its global service center to Mexico, hiring specialized talent while it set up its own entity.
Our team can deliver a quote while our Advisors build your tax strategy.